Insurance Dispute Lawyer in Montana & Wyoming

Trusted & Experienced attorneys

You deserve an experienced attorney to fight insurance claims for you. We have decades of experience and a passion for providing our community with the best quality legal support in Montana and Wyoming. We know your rights, and we’re ready to fight for them. Contact us to schedule a consultation with one of our attorneys.

Expert Team To Help You

Over 50 Years Of Combined Experience

Dedicated To Protecting People & Community

Top Rated Insurance Dispute Attorneys

Having an experienced team at your side is paramount when handling disputes with insurance companies. Insurance disputes can be complex and emotionally challenging, and it is impossible to wade through the legal world alone.

At Stinson Law Group, our team of expert insurance dispute lawyers can help you get the justice and compensation you deserve. We thoroughly review the policy in question to understand the terms, determine what the insurance company must be held accountable for, and ensure that you get the representation and advocacy you deserve.

Types of Insurance Disputes

There are different types of insurance disputes you may need an attorney for. Some common types of insurance disputes include: 

  • Denied claims: When an insurance company refuses to provide coverage or pay a claim submitted by an insured individual or their beneficiaries. 
  • Undervalued claims: When an insurance company offers a settlement amount that is significantly lower than the actual value of the claim. The insurance company may undervalue the extent of the damages, underestimate the financial impact on the insured individual or their beneficiaries, or use questionable evaluation methods. 
  • Delayed payments: If you’ve filed a claim, you expect your insurance company to pay you in a reasonable amount of time. If the company fails to uphold this expectation, you may be able to dispute it due to the delayed nature of the payment. 

These happen for many reasons, including policy exclusions, discrepancies in coverage, or bad faith practices by insurance companies. 

How an Attorney Can Help with Insurance Disputes

As experienced insurance dispute lawyers, we can help unravel the policy jargon in insurance policies and extrapolate your rights.  We bring expertise, legal knowledge, and advocacy skills to the table, ensuring that your rights are protected and you have the best chance of obtaining fair compensation for your losses in insurance disputes. 

Insurance policies can be unclear. It is not always obvious what you really signed up for. Some insurance companies will use this against you. We’ll help you understand the contract you signed and use that information to put you back in control of your rights.

We know your rights, and we can help you understand them, too. By partnering with Stinson Law Group, you’ll have a dedicated team negotiating with insurance companies, filing appeals on your behalf, and pursuing lawsuits if necessary.

Insurance Disputes By State

Should you find yourself in need of legal representation for an insurance dispute, it is imperative that you select a lawyer well-versed in the intricacies of your state’s laws. Each state boasts its own unique set of considerations when it comes to insurance claims, making it crucial to enlist the expertise of an attorney who possesses a deep understanding of these jurisdictional nuances.

For example, bad faith insurance occurs when insurance companies use various strategies and tactics to evade their contractual responsibilities towards their policyholders. However, what qualifies as bad faith differs from state to state. When you work with a qualified lawyer, they will be able to navigate these sometimes minute details.


In Wyoming, there are two main components that establish an insurer as acting in bad faith when it denies a claim. Firstly, it must be proven that there is no justifiable reason for the insurance company to deny the claim. Secondly, it must be shown that the insurer was fully aware of the absence of valid grounds for the claim denial.


Montana’s Unfair Claim Settlement Practices Act regulates the conduct of insurance companies in handling and settling insurance claims. The UCSPA is designed to protect policyholders and ensure fair treatment during the claims process. It outlines certain practices that are considered unfair or deceptive when performed by insurers.

The Montana law has 14 examples of unfair treatment, such as (1) misrepresenting pertinent facts or insurance policy provisions relating to coverages at issue; (2) fail to acknowledge and act reasonably promptly upon communications with respect to claims arising under insurance policies.

Why Choose Stinson Law Group

Our team of attorneys has helped our clients navigate the complex world of insurance disputes. Insurance companies get away with underpaying insurance claims because, too often, claimants don’t know their rights. That’s where we come in. Our goal is to ensure that you get the compensation you deserve from your insurance company. 


Decades of experience tell us to prepare all cases, big or small, for trial. A legal team that does not prepare your case for trial is an easy target for the other side and is likely to lose. The best settlement occurs when you, your lawyer, and your law team are ready for trial. At Stinson Law Group, we are ready for trial and the other side knows it.


Experience tells us using a “case team” best predicts a win. At Stinson Law Group our case team is a lead lawyer who will try your case if required, conduct settlement negotiations, and interact with the court and opposing counsel; a dedicated trial support legal team for research and document preparation; and an experienced paralegal for organization and investigation.


You should feel comfortable asking any question and get an understandable answer from your lawyer and their legal team. We pride ourselves on treating our clients respectfully, explaining things clearly, and answering all questions. This may well be your first time in the legal system, but we have thousands of hours of handling cases just like yours. We will guide you.

Free Initial Consultation

The Attorneys of Stinson Law Group practice personal injury, business, and criminal defense law statewide in both Wyoming and Montana. If you need help disputing unjust insurance claims, please contact us for a free consultation.

“When you have a legal issue, the system is tough to understand and impossible to navigate by yourself. It is a discouraging experience that leaves you feeling helpless. No person, family, or business should have to go through that alone. You need someone who will stand with you, and someone who can win for you. That person is Scott Stinson.”

— T. Fitzgerald, Stinson Law Group Client

“Ours is the only system in the world where one person, through the use of the legal system and a lawyer, can hold a business, a corporation or a person accountable for harm they caused.”

— Laurence Stinson, Partner, Stinson Law Group Client

“We felt from our first meeting we could put our trust in the Stinson Law Group and they would do their very best for us. The staff was always very kind and helpful anytime we called.”

— The Wakes, Stinson Law Group Client

“I highly recommend hiring the Stinson Law Group…! They are incredibly thorough, good communicators, and have a lot of experience to make you feel at ease with handling your case.”

— M. Joondeph, Stinson Law Group Client


Wrongful Death Compensation


Injury at Big Box Store


Tractor-Trailer vs. SUV